Info. de Gramática

N2 Lección 9: 11/23

(べつ)としてApart from, (Setting) aside, Whether or, Except for, Save for

Estructura

Noun + (べつ)として + Phrase
A(1) + ()+ B(1) + ()+ (べつ)として + Phrase
A(1) + ()+ (Antonym) A(1) + ()+ (べつ)として + Phrase
A(1) + かどうか(2) + (べつ)として + Phrase
A(1) + A[ない](1) + (べつ)として + Phrase

(1) Noun, [な]Adjective[い]Adjective、Verb
(2) (いな)

Detalles

  • Registro

    Standard

Acerca de は別として

(べつ)として is a set phrase with the meaning of 'setting aside (A)', 'except for (A)', or 'save for (A)'. This structure combines は, (べつ), a noun meaning 'difference', 'separation', or 'distinction', と, and the て-form of する. Due to this combination, the more literal meaning is 'going ahead with (A) as an exception', and just declares that (A) is something that is being completely disregarded before discussing the main point.

As は is simply marking the topic in the same way that it usually does, this phrase may be seen after a noun, or any other word that would usually be grouped with は. This frequently includes things like かどうか.

It is also fairly common to see the (A) word repeated in both its positive and negated form. This has the nuance of 'whether or not', in the same way as かどうか.

Despite this grammar structure being used to essentially remove (A) from what is being discussed, the primary reason for this is that (A) is usually an exception to some particular rule or constant that the speaker wants to highlight.

Caution

(べつ)として may occasionally be replaced by (べつ)にして, with little change in overall nuance. The use of と merely sounds more definitive, while に expresses that the speaker is intentionally separating (A).

Ejemplos

--:--

    手伝(てつだ)うべきかどうか(べつ)としてそもそも現場(げんば)にはいなかった。

    Leaving aside whether I should help or not, I wasn't at the scene in the first place.

    それ(べつ)としてもたぶん(おそ)かれ(はや)かれやそのトピックに(もど)ってくるだろう。

    Even if we set it aside, that topic will most likely resurface sooner or later.

    この子犬(こいぬ)はかわいい、かわいくない(べつ)として(たし)かに動物(どうぶつ)としては随分(ずいぶん)(かしこ)い。

    Leaving aside whether this puppy is cute or not, certainly, it is extremely smart for an animal.

    そのジョークを()うのはいいか(わる)いか(べつ)として自分(じぶん)ではとてもおもしろいと(おも)った!

    Leaving aside whether saying this joke is good or bad, I thought it was really funny.

    ()われている餌食(えじき)自身(じしん)(べつ)として()っている捕食(ほしょく)動物(どうぶつ)本当(ほんとう)(しあわ)せだ。

    (Setting) aside the prey that is being eaten, the predator enjoying its meal is surely happy.

  • ¡Obtén más oraciones de ejemplo!

    Nuestros subscriptores obtienen 12 oraciones de ejemplo en cada punto de Gramática.

Oraciones de Autoestudio

¡Estudia a tu manera!

Agrega tus propias oraciones y estudia con ellas a la par de las oraciones de Bunpro.

  • Digitales

      No hay recursos Digitales para「は別として」.

      Escríbenos para .


    • Literarios

        No hay recursos Literarios para「は別として」.

        Escríbenos para .

      • ¡Mira tu progreso!

        Bunpro ofrece referencias a libros y sitios muy útiles para complementar tu aprendizaje. Cada una es registrada individualmente para saber qué leíste ya.

      は別として – Discusión de Gramática

      Por el momento, no hay discusiones sobre は別として.

      ¡Sé la primer persona en preguntar y comienza a aprender con los demás usuarios de Bunpro!

      Comenzar Discusión